That, IMO, is really the pitfall many of you analytics fans make for yourselves. By using synthetic benchmarks, you look for things that can support whatever argument you want to make. confirmation bias with a mathematical twist.
I'm not faulting you for your philosophy, I'm just saying that my standards are less forgiving. The stats I favor are "W" over "L" Runs, dingers and RBI,... bro.... I'm Oldskool