The Willie Mays catch is often cited, but as good as it was, I think it's a little overrated.
For me.
Dwayne Wise.
A - Robbed a home run
B - Ran in to the wall
C - Bobbled it, but hung on
D - In the 9th ininning
E - Of a Perfecto
For the Tigers it was also in a Perfecto
Austin Jackson's 9th inning catch during the Imperfect Game. I have no idea how caught up to that ball. For me this beats out Curtis Granderson's HR theft in the 9th inning of a 1-0 game in Cleveland, where I literally fell out of my chair. AJ wins out because of the situation.
How about your plays..............