Al Avila joined this team as 2nd in command for player personnel in 2003, he became GM in 2015. So for 20 years he has been at or just next to the top and even before he was GM, he was in charge of scouting and his voice was the loudest in the room when it comes to drafting.
I went back to the 2004 draft and looked at position players the Tigers have drafted that has made it to the majors. (I am not counting DJ LeMahieu, who they drafted in the 41st round, didn't sign and then was drafted 2 years later in the 2nd round by the Cubs).
This is 20 fucking years. Are you ready for this?
Outfielders
Brennan Boesch
Nick Castellanos
Tyler Collins
Andy Dirks
Daniel Fields
Jeff Frazier
Mike Gerber
Derek Hill
Matt Joyce
Cameron Maybin
Jake Robson
Cristin Stewart
Steve Susdorf
Clete Thomas
Casper Wells
Infielders
David Adams
Kody Clemens
Brian Dlugach
Jeff Larish
Scott Sizemore
Devin Travis
Danny Worth
Catchers
Alex Avila
Curt Casali
Grayson Greiner
Bryan Holaday
James McCann
Chris Robinson
So, for 20 years of being at the top and being largely responsible for the draft, your starting lineup/roster would be
c - Alex Avila
1b - Jeff Larish
2b - Devin Travis
SS - Dany Worth
3b - Scott Sizemore
rf - Nick Castellanos
cf - Cameron Maybin
lf - Matt Joyce
DH - James McCann
Bench
Cristin Stewart, Brennan Boesch, Brian Dlugach, Kody Clemens
Oh my GOD, how is he allowed to continue his job? That's 20 years and the only respectable position players are Alex Avila, James McCann, Nick Castellanos, Devin Travis & Cameron Maybin. That's it.
It's so bad, it's just sooooo bad.
So when you see that my call is to fire everyone, I mean everyone. AJ too. Total clean sweep is needed.
EVERYONE !