I am not pessimistic about Keith long term, but yeah - they have to put him on a path he can follow and dig out of his hole. I still go back to two realities: Torres is not likely to re-sign with the Tigers, and in the 2nd half last season I think Colt was playing a decent 2b. In perfect world those two things would argue to send him back to Toledo to become the best 2B he can and when he does so well that Torres can be moved at the deadline he gets his gig back or he just comes back and everyone shares the AB with DH so there are enough to go around.
But it's not a perfect world - first because a guy is not going to like being jerked around by the org that way that course would play, but also because that means you've hitched your wagon to Torkelson. I'd love to be able to do that - but after at least another 150 or so PA to prove what we are seeing today. But if he doesn't snap out of it himself soon, a decision on Keith isn't going to wait another 50 games.
Harris is going to have to earn his salary figuring this one out.