He is making 28 mil, a lot, but underpaid. Keith can play 1B. We just don't know what Jobe can be. It's a risk. Clark will be good, but his aaa ops is now sub .800 and it's unknown if he'll be a star. Yordan has an injury history, as does Carp. This isn't something Harris would ever consider, but that's what it would take for the Astros to consider it. If Yordan stays healthy I would probably do it. The guy has raked from day 1 in his career.