Maybe hitting instruction during a major league season is a little like navigating a ship in the ocean—the captain can turn it only a little a time, and not on a 180 standing in place. The coaching may have established a plan during spring of for Tork to take first pitches if they are not in his happy zone, and then think about looking primarily for pitches he can drive. But maybe now that it’s not working, it’s nearly impossible to change his entire approach on a dime right ****ing now, while he is facing flamethrowing big league pitching literally every single day.
If coaching were to tell Tork, today, forget everything we told you this spring and simply change your approach immediately and swing at everything you think your bat can get to, not only is that going to call their entire coaching approach—one that is consistent with their organizational philosophy and that is working for other players on the team—into question, but it’s also going to butt up in his head against the instructions he got in spring that are still firmly in his mind, and create a confused mental state in which he is guessing and flailing on every pitch, instead of on mainly strike-two pitches.
I’m not speaking as an apologist for the hitting coaches here, but simply to the difficulty of revamping an entire hitting approach which almost always either takes place at the big league level only during the offseason, or on an extended developmental trip to the minors, which Tork might well benefit from. The monkey wrench here is that we do not have a regular first baseman who can man the spot every day for several weeks while Tork is away completely remakin g his hitting approach, especially now the Canha is down. And just going out and acquiring the warmest body available and sticking that guy at first base every day at least until at the break is almost certainly not going to make Tigers fans any happier when they see the results.
Go ahead and blame Harris if you like (and Hinch while yoou’re at it, because hell, why not) for not anticipating that Tork would completely stink up the joint and having a league-average starting first baseman just waiting around on the shelf to take over just in case, although I don’t think any team would have a contingency like that just ready to go. That’s a fan’s prerogative. But really, this looks like this is something Tork will just have to withstand for the next few weeks and try hard to figure out for himself at the major league level. This is definitely one of the hard parts of the game that every team goes through at some point.