Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)
19 minutes ago, casimir said:

justin-thompson-8060b254-7d27-4dfa-8312-f1a9dbdf869-resize-750.jpg

From the moment this guy came up, you could tell from the way he torqued his body during his delivery that he was an injury away from ending his career. That said, he did get a couple really good years out of his body.

Edited by chasfh
  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, chasfh said:

From the moment this guy came up, you could tell from the way he torqued his body during his delivery that he was an injury away from ending his career. That said, he did get a couple really good years out of his body.

I still hate that trade.

Posted (edited)
48 minutes ago, CaliforniaDreaming said:

I still hate that hat.

I hate the current orange bill one.  If they want an alternate lid to go with the alternate shirts, bring back this one:

item_116609_1_345564.jpg

That orange D with the white outline on the navy body with the navy lid is dope.

Edited by casimir
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Posted
1 hour ago, monkeytargets39 said:

I was more annoyed at losing Kapler and Catalonotto, but yeah we got fleeced hard

Frank was the one I rued letting go, although it's well known that Francisco Cordero was certainly the best piece we let go.

But what's little noted nor long remembered from that trade—the biggest swing and miss by the Tigers on it—was that the best subsequent career anyone in the trade ended up having was Gregg Zaun, whom we shipped off to the Royals before he ever stepped on the field for us, and who had five solid years with the Jays during the mid-2000s.

Lemondae out of lemons, though: had we kept Zaun through all those years, we may never have signed Pudge Rodriguez befpore the 2004 season.

Here's Claude's overview of the trade:

The Trade — November 2, 1999

Detroit sent to Texas: Francisco Cordero, Bill Haselman, Gabe Kapler, Justin Thompson, Frank Catalanotto, Alan Webb (minors) Texas sent to Detroit: Juan González, Danny Patterson, Gregg Zaun


WAR Delivered Directly to Each Trade Partner

Detroit received (WAR accrued while on DET):

Player DET WAR Seasons
Juan González 1.7 2000 only
Danny Patterson 1.3 2000–2004
Gregg Zaun 0.0 Never played for DET
Total 3.0  

Texas received (WAR accrued while on TEX):

Player TEX WAR Seasons
Francisco Cordero 7.9 2000–2006
Frank Catalanotto 5.5 2000–2002, 2007–2008
Gabe Kapler 1.5 2000–2002
Bill Haselman 1.2 2000–2002
Justin Thompson -0.2 2005 only
Total 16.0  

Texas won the direct exchange by more than 5-to-1 (16.0 WAR vs. 3.0). Zaun — arguably Detroit's best return — never wore a Tigers uniform; he went straight to Kansas City.


Total Post-Trade Career WAR by Player (All Teams)

Detroit's haul:

Player Total WAR Teams
Gregg Zaun 14.0 KCR, HOU, COL, TOR, BAL, TBR, MIL
Juan González 8.0 DET, CLE, TEX, KCR
Danny Patterson 1.3 DET
Total 23.2  

Texas's haul:

Player Total WAR Teams
Francisco Cordero 12.3 TEX, MIL, CIN, TOR, HOU
Frank Catalanotto 11.4 TEX, TOR, MIL, NYM
Gabe Kapler 3.7 TEX, COL, BOS, MIL, TBR
Bill Haselman 1.1 TEX, BOS
Justin Thompson -0.2 TEX
Total 28.4  

WAR That Flowed to Third Parties

From Detroit's players:

Player Team WAR
Gregg Zaun KCR 1.9
Gregg Zaun HOU -1.1
Gregg Zaun COL 0.1
Gregg Zaun TOR 8.1
Gregg Zaun BAL 2.4
Gregg Zaun TBR 1.2
Gregg Zaun MIL 1.3
Juan González CLE 4.3
Juan González TEX 2.4
Juan González KCR -0.5

From Texas's players:

Player Team WAR
Frank Catalanotto TOR 6.1
Frank Catalanotto MIL 0.1
Frank Catalanotto NYM -0.3
Francisco Cordero MIL 2.8
Francisco Cordero CIN 2.4
Francisco Cordero TOR -0.5
Francisco Cordero HOU -0.4
Gabe Kapler COL -0.5
Gabe Kapler BOS 0.7
Gabe Kapler MIL 1.7
Gabe Kapler TBR 0.3
Bill Haselman BOS -0.1

The single biggest beneficiary of this entire trade was Toronto, which collected 8.1 WAR from Zaun (2004–2008) and 6.1 WAR from Catalanotto (2003–2006) — 14.2 WAR total, more than either trade partner received directly. Cleveland's haul of González (4.3 WAR in 2001 alone) was more than Detroit ever got from him.

 

Posted

I just realized because this is on FOX I won’t be able to watch it because I live “Out West“ where everybody and I mean everybody on earth simply love love love love love loves the Los Angeles Dodgers. Not.

Fortunately, I have a social function tonight that precludes following this game very closely anyway so good luck to you all.

IMG_0343.gif.35e455cc55ebcacb6ded7f0b78afafea.gif

Posted
3 hours ago, chasfh said:

Frank was the one I rued letting go, although it's well known that Francisco Cordero was certainly the best piece we let go.

But what's little noted nor long remembered from that trade—the biggest swing and miss by the Tigers on it—was that the best subsequent career anyone in the trade ended up having was Gregg Zaun, whom we shipped off to the Royals before he ever stepped on the field for us, and who had five solid years with the Jays during the mid-2000s.

Lemondae out of lemons, though: had we kept Zaun through all those years, we may never have signed Pudge Rodriguez befpore the 2004 season.

Here's Claude's overview of the trade:

The Trade — November 2, 1999

Detroit sent to Texas: Francisco Cordero, Bill Haselman, Gabe Kapler, Justin Thompson, Frank Catalanotto, Alan Webb (minors) Texas sent to Detroit: Juan González, Danny Patterson, Gregg Zaun


WAR Delivered Directly to Each Trade Partner

Detroit received (WAR accrued while on DET):

Player DET WAR Seasons
Juan González 1.7 2000 only
Danny Patterson 1.3 2000–2004
Gregg Zaun 0.0 Never played for DET
Total 3.0  

Texas received (WAR accrued while on TEX):

Player TEX WAR Seasons
Francisco Cordero 7.9 2000–2006
Frank Catalanotto 5.5 2000–2002, 2007–2008
Gabe Kapler 1.5 2000–2002
Bill Haselman 1.2 2000–2002
Justin Thompson -0.2 2005 only
Total 16.0  

Texas won the direct exchange by more than 5-to-1 (16.0 WAR vs. 3.0). Zaun — arguably Detroit's best return — never wore a Tigers uniform; he went straight to Kansas City.


Total Post-Trade Career WAR by Player (All Teams)

Detroit's haul:

Player Total WAR Teams
Gregg Zaun 14.0 KCR, HOU, COL, TOR, BAL, TBR, MIL
Juan González 8.0 DET, CLE, TEX, KCR
Danny Patterson 1.3 DET
Total 23.2  

Texas's haul:

Player Total WAR Teams
Francisco Cordero 12.3 TEX, MIL, CIN, TOR, HOU
Frank Catalanotto 11.4 TEX, TOR, MIL, NYM
Gabe Kapler 3.7 TEX, COL, BOS, MIL, TBR
Bill Haselman 1.1 TEX, BOS
Justin Thompson -0.2 TEX
Total 28.4  

WAR That Flowed to Third Parties

From Detroit's players:

Player Team WAR
Gregg Zaun KCR 1.9
Gregg Zaun HOU -1.1
Gregg Zaun COL 0.1
Gregg Zaun TOR 8.1
Gregg Zaun BAL 2.4
Gregg Zaun TBR 1.2
Gregg Zaun MIL 1.3
Juan González CLE 4.3
Juan González TEX 2.4
Juan González KCR -0.5

From Texas's players:

Player Team WAR
Frank Catalanotto TOR 6.1
Frank Catalanotto MIL 0.1
Frank Catalanotto NYM -0.3
Francisco Cordero MIL 2.8
Francisco Cordero CIN 2.4
Francisco Cordero TOR -0.5
Francisco Cordero HOU -0.4
Gabe Kapler COL -0.5
Gabe Kapler BOS 0.7
Gabe Kapler MIL 1.7
Gabe Kapler TBR 0.3
Bill Haselman BOS -0.1

The single biggest beneficiary of this entire trade was Toronto, which collected 8.1 WAR from Zaun (2004–2008) and 6.1 WAR from Catalanotto (2003–2006) — 14.2 WAR total, more than either trade partner received directly. Cleveland's haul of González (4.3 WAR in 2001 alone) was more than Detroit ever got from him.

 

Haha, wanna resurrect the debate about Easley & Catalanotto vs Cruz & Easley as the better keystone combo?

Posted
1 hour ago, IdahoBert said:

McGonigle SS

 

Torres 2B

 

Keith 3B

 

Greene, R LF

 

Dingler C

 

Carpenter RF

 

Torkelson 1B

 

Pérez, W CF

 

Jung, Ja DH

I hate the DH batting last.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      330
    • Most Online
      796

    Newest Member
    MSCG
    Joined
  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...