Valverde having to throw pitch 30+ in relief quickly burned him out.
I liked Phil Coke, and enjoy drunk Phil Coke when they do the reunions, but as a closer that was a temporary fix.
Benoit was a good setup man.
Zumaya was friggin awesome as a setup man except I attended the one game when he gave up a HR in relief against the Cubs, with all those Cub fans at Comerica...it upset me. Luckily the Tigers came back and won that game.
Todd Jones was a heart attack as a closer