I don't know... Holmes picked a starting CB, he got what appears to be a starting OL in the sixth round, and got a core special teams piece in the 4th round. That's not bad. NFL dot com rates it a C- but a big part of their analysis was how much playing time the draft picks got, so this is in some way also a measure of the weakness of the rosters of the teams who threw their rookies right in. If Manu develops and it turns out Holmes ended up replacing 2/5 of his starting OL for ten years with a 4th and 6th round pick, he will look like a genius.