It seems like people are interpreting "control the strike zone" as meaning Harris and Hinch want their hitters to take as many pitches as humanly possible even if it gets them into 0-2 counts they have to fight their way out of, or even taking three pitches down the pipe and walking back to the dugout proud of their part in sticking to the strategy, but I don't think merely taking pitches without thinking is what Harris and Hinch are aiming for.
I think what they want is for hitters to focus on swinging on pitches that are in the strike zone to put them in play, versus swinging on balls well outside the strike zone and missing and expanding the zone for the pitcher. It's also about having to plan to attack the strike zone and sticking to the plan even after strike one.
If that's what it's about, if it's about attacking the zone and swinging at ball thrown within it, then why are so many guys watching strike one go down the pipe and then struggling to put the barrel on middle-middle? I think the main reasons out players are struggling with that at the big league level is not because the strategy is a steaming pile of freshly-dumped ****, but that they have habits ingrained through the years they're having trouble fighting through; or they have mental lapses and have trouble consistently putting the strategy into practice; or they get frustrated at times and forget the strategy in a bid to change everything with one swing; or they are simply not good hitters and won't be here for the long term anyway; or they are shortstops on the back half of their career who have checked out and can't be reached.
Controlling the zone is preached throughout the minors as well. That's why we see most of our farm teams toward the top in walks and OPS, and toward the bottom in strikeouts. Lakeland is a shining example of this, and is really the first team completely put together by the Harris regime. The teams toward the top of the system still have the remnants of the prior regime, with players whose habits are more ingrained and more difficult to iron out.
So I can see how the strategy is not going to help us play into November so much this year, not because the strategy is ****ing asinine and everyone connected to it should be catapulted into the sun, but because we just don't have the horses in-house yet to effectively win rings with it. We might do marginally better with some members of this group as the season progresses and the coaches refine the approach, but we're probably not going to have a team epiphany and lead the league in runs from this day forward. Bottom line is, the strategy of controlling the strike zone from the batter's box is not going away, and I don't believe it should go away, anyway.