-
Posts
9,773 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
31
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Blogs
Store
Articles
Everything posted by MichiganCardinal
-
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
I remember Marvin Lewis was also interviewed. Was the only name connected to the Lions that I didn’t like at all. -
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
From Justin Rogers: “Point of clarify for what it matters, conversations between the Lions and Matt Campbell never progressed to an offer in 2021.” Matt Campbell is full of ****. No one at Iowa State declines an NFL job offer after progressing to the offer stage in order to stay at freaking Iowa State. Is it possible Matt Campbell saw the writing on the wall that he wasn’t going to get hired by the Lions, so he quietly withdrew from consideration? Maybe. But he was never offered and it’s insulting to Dan Campbell for him to just come and claim Dan was the Lions second choice. -
-
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Just wait until he learns he can use two hands! -
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
All I said was that the trade was worth it in my eyes. TeSlaa showed real promise last year in a very limited role. Random 3rd round picks, whether selected by a good GM in Holmes or an unproven GM (to be kind) in Gladstone, are closer to late round lottery picks than sure-fire contributors. Holmes has picked Alim McNeill, Iffy Melifonwu, Kerby Joseph, Hendon Hooker, Brodric Martin, and Isaac TeSlaa in the third round. Go back another five years to get another GM’s perspective, Quinn took Julian Okwara, Jonah Jackson, Will Harris, Tracy Walker, Kenny Golladay, and Graham Glasgow in the 3rd round. It’s hit and miss. If a GM I trust like Holmes sees an Alim/Kerby type in the 3rd round, I’m okay with him sacrificing picks that are more likely (in his mind) to become Brodric Martin than the guy he’s going up to get. To say “yeah but the picks he gave up could have been TWO Alim/Kerby types” is painting a picture of the draft board like very likely doesn’t exist, or at the very least is entirely unrealistic for the kind of scouting skills any NFL team has. -
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Worth it in my book. -
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Can't say I'll lose any sleep over this list. Maybe Reader would have been nice depth, but they replaced him with youth which is fine. Maulet and Cunningham are maybe a little surprising just in terms of the depth at those positions, though they're both older guys who again could be replaced with youth. -
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Hopefully they get it done with Campbell. This was the same plan and the same reasoning the Ravens tried with Linderbaum though that led to a bad team with lots of money backing up a Brinks truck. Granted, a center’s relationship to a quarterback is not comparable to an off-ball linebacker. -
Question: Can Derrick Moore turn into Maxx Crosby 2.0?
MichiganCardinal replied to 1984Echoes's topic in Detroit Lions
Good thing we learned from Manu and aren’t setting unrealistic expectations. -
2026 Detroit Lions Offseason Thread
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
2026 Post-Draft Depth Chart I put a line ( | ) where it felt like a general "no sweat training camp" ended. Everyone to the right is likely fighting for a job, though some (like Rakestraw and Frazier) may have an inside track relative to others, and certainly a 7th round (and maybe even a 6th round) rookie can easily fall to the right of that line with a bad camp. Underline is a veteran addition, bold is a draft pick, italics is a UDFA signing. QB (2/3): Jared Goff, Teddy Bridgewater | Luke Altmyer RB (3/6): Jahmyr Gibbs, Isiah Pacheco, Sione Vaki | Jacob Saylors, Jabari Smalls, Kye Robichaux WR (5/9): Amon-Ra St. Brown, Jameson Williams, Isaac TeSlaa, Greg Dortch, Kendrick Law | Dominic Lovett, Tom Kennedy, Jackson Meeks, Malik Cunningham TE (2/6): Sam LaPorta, Brock Wright | Tyler Conklin, Zach Horton, Thomas Gordon, Miles Kitselman OT (3/5): Penei Sewell, Blake Miller, Larry Borom | Giovanni Manu, Devin Cochran IOL (4/11): Tate Ratledge, Cade Mays, Christian Mahogony, Juice Scruggs | Ben Bartch, Miles Frazier, Michael Niese, Colby Sorsdal, Seth McLaughlin, Mason Miller, Melvin Priestly EDGE (3/8): Aidan Hutchinson, Derrick Moore, DJ Wonnum | Payton Turner, Ahmad Hassanein, Tyler Lacy, Eric O'Neill, Anthony Lucas IDL (5/9): Alim McNeill, Tyleik Williams, Levi Onwuzurike, Skyler Gill-Howard, Tyre West | Mekhi Wingo, Myles Adams, Chris Smith, Aidan Keanaaina LB (4/7): Jack Campbell, Derrick Barnes, Malcolm Rodriguez, Jimmy Rolder | Damone Clark, Trevor Nowaske, Erick Hunter CB (5/9): DJ Reed, Terrion Arnold, Roger McCreary, Rock Ya-Sin, Keith Abney | Ennis Rakestraw, Khalil Dorsey, Nick Whiteside, De'Shawn Rucker DB (3/9): Kerby Joseph, Christian Izien, Avonte Maddox, [Brian Branch-PUP] | Chuck Clark, Loren Strickland, Dan Jackson, Thomas Harper, Aamaris Brown ST (3/3): Jack Fox, Jake Bates, Hogan Hatten Initial look with 85/90 spots filled says there's a lot of turnover, but not a lot of glaring holes. It wouldn't hurt to have more security in the defensive backfield, but Kerby is such an unknown to us. If he's 100% it's probably fine until Branch gets back. If he's not, that looks like a hole. Additional linebacker depth wouldn't hurt either, since the Lions tend to use linebackers on special teams quite a bit. The camp battles will mostly come in the trenches and the defensive backfield. Currently 42 spots are already filled by my rough estimation, leaving 11 spots for 48 guys. -
Grading the Detroit Lions 2023 Draft
MichiganCardinal replied to Motor City Sonics's topic in Detroit Lions
Martin was more disappointing than Hooker. They traded three picks to go get him and most analysts had him as a late day three prospect. He was just supposed to be a Snacks Harrison type, plugging holes and absorbing blockers. But he was never even strong enough to win a one-on-one. Hooker was in the Heisman conversation before his ACL injury, and wouldn’t have whiffed the 3rd round without the injury. Holmes also traded down twice before making the pick. And, we hadn’t yet extended Goff and needed something of leverage in those negotiations, because there was nothing behind Goff at the position. I’ll take Hooker and Martin all day if it brings me those first four picks though. Easy A draft. Maybe A+. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
I’d like to see Joseph be more than “trending” in the right direction by now. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Not to mention he’s lost thousands of dollars on betting the last few years. I only visit the site nowadays for Charlie Campbell. If he broke off into his own site I’d jump ship in a heartbeat. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Still available: - Jermod McCoy, CB, Tennessee - Connor Lew, C, Auburn - Jalon Kilgore, DB, South Carolina - Dani Dennis-Sutton, EDGE, Penn State - Kyle Louis, LB, Pitt - Keith Abney, CB, Arizona State - Malik Muhammad, CB, Texas - Domani Jackson, CB, Alabama - Will Lee III, CB, Texas A&M - Kamari Ramsey, DB, USC - LT Overton, DT/DE, Alabama - Joshua Josephs, EDGE, Tennessee - Anthony Lucas, EDGE, USC - Jalen Farmer, OG, Kentucky - Billy Schrauth, OG, Notre Dame - Anez Cooper, OG, Miami - Drew Shelton, OL, Penn State - Isaiah World, OT, Oregon - Deonte Lawson, LB, Alabama - Nick Singleton, RB, Penn State - Mike Washington, RB, Arkansas -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
The worst I’ve seen was one from a Twitter doctor (who are very hit and miss because they’re literally providing medical opinions on individuals who are not their patients). The good ones tend to merely make informed opinions based on video. This seems like nonsense based on media reports to maximize engagement. Only the team docs know for sure I guess. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
My understanding wasn’t that he would miss 2026. It was more that there were concerns the knee was a ticking time bomb and would eventually shorten his career. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
I still think Brad wants McCoy. If we get into the 90s, 118, one of our 5ths, and a 2027 day three pick would probably get it done. Hard to imagine he falls all the way to 118. The 4th round is the beginning of the lottery. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Dammit I liked Sam Roush a lot. Highly athletic tight end. Could have done a lot of good as a Brock Wright replacement. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
The whole military complex the NFL has absorbed is so ridiculously over the top. I’ll stay off the soap box for now, but I’m like a step away. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
I’m not sure the Lions are done tonight but it’s probably going to be a while still. They have 118, plus two 5ths, two 6ths, and a 7th. Lots of capital but none of it good. We do have our own 2027 3rd, the 3rd we traded for TeSlaa was the comp pick we got for Glenn. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Jags took a 25-year-old blocking tight end. First name I didn’t recognize. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
I’m a bit over McAfee’s schtick -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Minter was playing 4D chess underutilizing him at Michigan. -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Packers take Cisse over McCoy. If they took McCoy I’d have been worried he was going to be our Brian Branch (the taking him in the second round part, not the flipping off the fans part) -
2026 Live Draft Thread As It Happens
MichiganCardinal replied to Mr.TaterSalad's topic in Detroit Lions
Moore is the kind of high floor, low ceiling prospect I like in the 3rd round, not the 2nd. I haven’t seen film on him yet but my impression from what I’d read was actually opposite of that that Reisman posted from dpbrugler, whoever that is. At 6’3/255 he’s a little smaller than other Holmes defensive linemen. There was some concern that he would get pushed back by larger NFL offensive linemen and lose contain in the run game. To the extent the hope was for a pass rusher, I think this is as close as Holmes is going to get.
