That’s a pretty decent point I hadn’t contemplated before. The luxury tax may have been designed more to suppress top end salaries, which keeps the average and median salaries down over time, than to help teams be competitive against one another, since we have seen franchises like Oakland and Tampa and Cleveland win year after year with some of the lowest payrolls in the game. It may also be that TPTB prefer the teams they know will spend the highest, basically the Big Six, be those that actually do so, because those are the most popular teams that will sign the highest-priced, biggest-name superstars that will help grow the game worldwide.
Of course, given the way franchises make money nowadays—through gameday media, the national network, licensing, merchandising, and digital more than through ticket sales, concessions, or (lol) winning—the “poorest” franchises are rolling in dough, the billionaires and hedge funds that own them are like pigs in ****, and their fans can all go pound sand. We are actually lucky, and no more, that the Tigers, seemingly against all odds, awoke to become a franchise that’s breaking out of that golden trash can by hiring Scott Harris, the catalyst move which is changing everything.