Technically true as this is, the cap players go into the Hall with means something to most ardent fans, probably because we tend to be fans more of teams than individual players.
I would like to see Verlander go in as a Tiger. I'm a slappy that way. To the degree it's important at all in the big scheme of things, which is not really, it's important to me. Until just recently there would be a good chance he would go in as an Astro, especially after he won his second ring and his second Cy Young with them. They supercharged his late career and made him the winner practically all players long to be. When he went back to the Astros last year I thought he might retire with them and cement his legacy with their franchise. But he was terrible for them last year, so the Astros let him go, and now he's flailing with the Giants at the moment, so I think there's significantly less chance now that he goes in as an Astro.
Part of it depends on how he finishes up. If he retires as a Giant, I think it's much better than 50/50 he goes in as a Tiger than as an Astro. BUT: if he were sign a one-day contract with one or the other team and he retires with that team, I think that's the cap he's going to wear to Cooperstown. And he has a reason to sign that ceremonial contract with either team.