Tiger337 Posted 13 hours ago Posted 13 hours ago (edited) 20 minutes ago, Sports_Freak said: Not with Keith signed for long term. Its his position in '26. Maybe next year when Torres may be gone. Or if Keith gets hurt... Keith and Torres were on the roster last year too and they didn't use Keith at third until later in the year and even then he alternated between 3b and DH. He'll probably get the majority of at bats at 3B to start the season, but I wouldn't say he was rock solid at the position. Edited 13 hours ago by Tiger337 Quote
Tiger337 Posted 13 hours ago Posted 13 hours ago 11 minutes ago, Sports_Freak said: Nobody ever makes a team with a strong spring...OK. 👍 They can make the team by showing real improvement in skills over past years. If they have good numbers, but they don't show pysical readiness, they won't make the team. Often times both will happen at the same time. 1 Quote
Longgone Posted 13 hours ago Posted 13 hours ago (edited) 34 minutes ago, Sports_Freak said: Nobody ever makes a team with a strong spring...OK. 👍 If Clark goes 6 for 20 and catches every ball, he's still the same player, with the same abilities, at the same level of development, and he'd be in the exact same situation. The coaches understand this and are not basing their judgements on superficial stats. Same with McGonigle, if he was hitting a buck fifty, but showing the same abilities and development, he'd be in the same position. Edited 12 hours ago by Longgone Quote
Sports_Freak Posted 12 hours ago Posted 12 hours ago 38 minutes ago, Tiger337 said: They can make the team by showing real improvement in skills over past years. If they have good numbers, but they don't show pysical readiness, they won't make the team. Often times both will happen at the same time. And sometimes if it's an open competition at a position of need. Quote
Sports_Freak Posted 12 hours ago Posted 12 hours ago 43 minutes ago, Tiger337 said: Keith and Torres were on the roster last year too and they didn't use Keith at third until later in the year and even then he alternated between 3b and DH. He'll probably get the majority of at bats at 3B to start the season, but I wouldn't say he was rock solid at the position. Was it his arm still recovering from injuries? I seem to remember fans saying he had a weak arm last season. Quote
gehringer_2 Posted 11 hours ago Posted 11 hours ago (edited) 1 hour ago, Sports_Freak said: Was it his arm still recovering from injuries? I seem to remember fans saying he had a weak arm last season. IIRC -He hurt his shoulder going into a base while still in the minors so they swapped him and Jung 2nd and third because the shoulder. At the time they said it could take a year or two for it to regain full strength, if it did. So he was tooling along as a 2B then they signed Torres but also figured Tork was toast so he was a 1b, and then when when Tork wasn't, it was - well share the ABs as best we can, and then finally: "Well how is the arm doing now? Try 3rd again" Last year once they put him back there he seemed to be throwing OK and there were no issues, so he is back where he started. He doesn't have anything like a cannon, but he gets rid of the ball quick and he's accurate. I'm guessing some people got a little misled looking at statcast data because you just don't try to throw max effort at 2b so his throwing velo looked pretty low, but at third he was hitting upper 80s, and with regular throwing there who knows he might loosen up and be able to add to that. Edited 11 hours ago by gehringer_2 Quote
IdahoBert Posted 10 hours ago Posted 10 hours ago This March 11 game of the Tigers at the Twins either the Twins are really crappy hitters or all the Tigers pitchers on this “bullpen day” are really good. No runs scored against Detroit pitching but not many Ks either. The Tigers hitters have already struck out 13 times in eight innings. Quote
IdahoBert Posted 10 hours ago Posted 10 hours ago 18 minutes ago, IdahoBert said: This March 11 game of the Tigers at the Twins either the Twins are really crappy hitters or all the Tigers pitchers on this “bullpen day” are really good. No runs scored against Detroit pitching but not many Ks either. The Tigers hitters have already struck out 13 times in eight innings. Two Tiger’s pitchers allow runs, so it’s a loss but at least it wasn’t a tie. Quote
Sports_Freak Posted 9 hours ago Posted 9 hours ago 1 hour ago, gehringer_2 said: IIRC -He hurt his shoulder going into a base while still in the minors so they swapped him and Jung 2nd and third because the shoulder. At the time they said it could take a year or two for it to regain full strength, if it did. So he was tooling along as a 2B then they signed Torres but also figured Tork was toast so he was a 1b, and then when when Tork wasn't, it was - well share the ABs as best we can, and then finally: "Well how is the arm doing now? Try 3rd again" Last year once they put him back there he seemed to be throwing OK and there were no issues, so he is back where he started. He doesn't have anything like a cannon, but he gets rid of the ball quick and he's accurate. I'm guessing some people got a little misled looking at statcast data because you just don't try to throw max effort at 2b so his throwing velo looked pretty low, but at third he was hitting upper 80s, and with regular throwing there who knows he might loosen up and be able to add to that. Yeah, I guess his defense, at third last year, appeared decent. I don’t know the advanced stats though. But his hitting wasn't all that great, I guess passable but we may see Javy starting against LH pitchers, IDK what Hinch has planned. I doubt the Tigers will carry Jung on the roster as just a backup for Tork. Maybe Keith will be Tork's backup? Who else for 1st base? Quote
Sports_Freak Posted 9 hours ago Posted 9 hours ago 56 minutes ago, IdahoBert said: Two Tiger’s pitchers allow runs, so it’s a loss but at least it wasn’t a tie. All of these ties in the regular season would allow the Tigers to set a Major League record!! Quote
IdahoBert Posted 3 hours ago Posted 3 hours ago UPCOMING GAMES – Thursday, March 12 Verlander against the Yankees in Lakeland Friday, March 13 Casey Mize against the Pirates in Lakeland Saturday, March 14 Skubal against Toronto and Max Scherzer in Dunedin Quote
gehringer_2 Posted 3 hours ago Posted 3 hours ago 6 hours ago, Sports_Freak said: Yeah, I guess his defense, at third last year, appeared decent. I don’t know the advanced stats though. .. I don't know that it ever gets talked about much but the strongest arm on the Tiger IF is McKinstry's. He'll touch mid 90's. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.