Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Ever hear of the cube root rule?

What is the Cube Root Rule in politics?

The Cube Root Rule in politics is a principle that suggests the optimal size of a country’s legislative body (e.g., parliament or congress) should be roughly the cube root of the country’s population. This rule is often used as a guideline to help determine the appropriate number of representatives in a legislature to ensure effective representation and governance.

How the Cube Root Rule Works:

  • Calculation: According to the rule, if a country’s population is PPP, the ideal size of its legislative body SSS should be approximately S=P1/3. For instance, if a country has a population of 27 million, the optimal legislative body size would be about 300 members, as 27,000,0001/3 = 300

Rationale Behind the Cube Root Rule:

  • Balance of Representation: The rule aims to strike a balance between having enough representatives to provide effective representation for citizens and not having so many that the legislative process becomes inefficient.
  • Historical Observation: The rule is based on empirical observation of various countries, where many legislative bodies approximate the cube root of their populations.
  • Scalability: It provides a scalable approach, meaning as populations grow, legislatures should expand at a manageable rate, avoiding the extremes of overrepresentation or underrepresentation.

Cube Root Rule in practice in the US:

us-house-sube-root.jpg 

Posted
Just now, CMRivdogs said:

Gonna need to build a bigger Capitol Building. Should be right up Trump's alley, he likes to build stuff

Edit, this was meant  for Cube Root/expanding the House

Posted
6 hours ago, chasfh said:

Ever hear of the cube root rule?

What is the Cube Root Rule in politics?

The Cube Root Rule in politics is a principle that suggests the optimal size of a country’s legislative body (e.g., parliament or congress) should be roughly the cube root of the country’s population. This rule is often used as a guideline to help determine the appropriate number of representatives in a legislature to ensure effective representation and governance.

How the Cube Root Rule Works:

  • Calculation: According to the rule, if a country’s population is PPP, the ideal size of its legislative body SSS should be approximately S=P1/3. For instance, if a country has a population of 27 million, the optimal legislative body size would be about 300 members, as 27,000,0001/3 = 300

Rationale Behind the Cube Root Rule:

  • Balance of Representation: The rule aims to strike a balance between having enough representatives to provide effective representation for citizens and not having so many that the legislative process becomes inefficient.
  • Historical Observation: The rule is based on empirical observation of various countries, where many legislative bodies approximate the cube root of their populations.
  • Scalability: It provides a scalable approach, meaning as populations grow, legislatures should expand at a manageable rate, avoiding the extremes of overrepresentation or underrepresentation.

Cube Root Rule in practice in the US:

us-house-sube-root.jpg 

I don't know about 700 (which is what the cube root would give for 350M, but the US House should be expanded to at least 500 - and that requires nothing but an act of Congress. But the real problem with representation is the Senate and that's a tougher nut to crack.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...