I get that there’s a risk for pitchers….but if we aren’t going to pony up for Skubal, then who would we ever go after? Even when he hits free agency after next year, he will still be on the right side of 30, has a triple crown, a multiple time all-star, a cy young winner, and aside from his one injury—has been very durable. He even recovered from that injury quickly and effectively. He’s got a strong frame, good mechanics (although the leg kick may not age well) and is an ultra-competitor.
Id much rather sign him for what he brings to the table than continue to shuffle around guys like Cobb/Flaherty/Maeda/etc. and ultimately spend 30-40 million a year on hoping they bounce back and fill out a rotation. Plus we aren’t going to have to really pay up big in the next several years on Jobe/Olson/Melton…so why not allocate the money to keep Skubal? If he gets hurt, he gets hurt. If he doesn’t, then we have our pitcher of the generation who can anchor a rotation for the next decade.
Plus it’s not a great look to trade him or let him walk when the current core of the fan base just watched us get next to nothing for Verlander, Scherzer, Sanchez, JD Martinez, Suarez and Adames.