Nicely answered. I'm not sure how we can go back in time and draft Wyatt Langford with so clear a 20-20 hindsight crystal ball at our disposal ...
I think Harris might have been looking at the disaster that Avila left behind and figured, reasonably so, that we would not have had the horses in house to support Skubal during his remaining 3-1/2 years (at the time) with the team; that we could not have bought our way to immediate contention with either money or the prospect capital we had at hand; and that by the time we could have built up to a level of contender that a front-liner like Skubal could headline, he would be choosing from among multiple offers from Big Six teams.
So, in a way, our contending way ahead of schedule kind of ****ed up that part of the plan. Who knew when Scott Harris came aboard that we were going to win well into October the very next year with guys like Javy and McKinstry and Wenceel and Carpenter and Parker Meadows and a bunch of waiver wire and one-year guys leading the way—and hell, with even Tork? No one in August, 2023 could have foreseen that. So it made sense that we were planning on building more slowly than that, and would probably have to start fielding the winning Tiger teams with Skubal already having a foot out the door. I think that would have been a fact of life most of us would have accepted up to and including July of 2024.
But then, out of nowhere, we start winning and surprise the whole baseball world last year—so why not throw all the chips onto the table and go for broke, 2025 or bust? That's what Dombrowski would have done, right? Damn right that's what he would have done. And that's fine if all anyone cares about is 2025, and that the following year is for 2026 us to worry about. But that's not how Harris, and now Baby Doc Ilitch, see things. They know stuff fans generally don't, such as, there was no chance on god's green earth Shohei Ohtani and Juan Soto were ever going to come to Detroit. Heck, you even said yourself that we tried our damnedest to get Bregman, who's clearly a cut below Ohtani/Soto, fielding the best offer by far, and he still wouldn't come to Detroit. Now multiple that by every top-tier free agent of the last ten years. And we don't know what what kind of trades Harris has been turning down that past two years, but I would bet money they looked a lot like the trades Al Avila was falling for and became the laughingstock of baseball over.
So, I guess in the end, the answer would have been for Harris to thread the needle perfectly and get the deadline exactly right, such as trading for O'Hearn but passing on Suarez; or somehow getting the Twins to send us Duran while we pass on pundit favorite Helsley. As it was, Harris scored huge with Finnegan, but all anyone will be talking about is how he failed tonight.
In the final analysis, no matter what he does, Harris sucks. That's the nature of his job, I guess. As for what I think about it, all I know is this: Scott Harris has gotten us to back-to-back LDSes well ahead of schedule. And I'm going to trust that he's going to continue to move us forward, until he proves to me that he isn't. And when that happens, I'll get big mad at him, just like everyone else is doing now. But until then, I'm going to look at 2024 and 2025 as a bonus and not a birthright, and I look forward to seeing what's in store for us in 2026. And I will go out on a limb and bet that Harris surprises us by demonstrating that we are not just another Tampa Bay Rays after all.