Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Ever hear of the cube root rule?

What is the Cube Root Rule in politics?

The Cube Root Rule in politics is a principle that suggests the optimal size of a country’s legislative body (e.g., parliament or congress) should be roughly the cube root of the country’s population. This rule is often used as a guideline to help determine the appropriate number of representatives in a legislature to ensure effective representation and governance.

How the Cube Root Rule Works:

  • Calculation: According to the rule, if a country’s population is PPP, the ideal size of its legislative body SSS should be approximately S=P1/3. For instance, if a country has a population of 27 million, the optimal legislative body size would be about 300 members, as 27,000,0001/3 = 300

Rationale Behind the Cube Root Rule:

  • Balance of Representation: The rule aims to strike a balance between having enough representatives to provide effective representation for citizens and not having so many that the legislative process becomes inefficient.
  • Historical Observation: The rule is based on empirical observation of various countries, where many legislative bodies approximate the cube root of their populations.
  • Scalability: It provides a scalable approach, meaning as populations grow, legislatures should expand at a manageable rate, avoiding the extremes of overrepresentation or underrepresentation.

Cube Root Rule in practice in the US:

us-house-sube-root.jpg 

Posted
Just now, CMRivdogs said:

Gonna need to build a bigger Capitol Building. Should be right up Trump's alley, he likes to build stuff

Edit, this was meant  for Cube Root/expanding the House

Posted
6 hours ago, chasfh said:

Ever hear of the cube root rule?

What is the Cube Root Rule in politics?

The Cube Root Rule in politics is a principle that suggests the optimal size of a country’s legislative body (e.g., parliament or congress) should be roughly the cube root of the country’s population. This rule is often used as a guideline to help determine the appropriate number of representatives in a legislature to ensure effective representation and governance.

How the Cube Root Rule Works:

  • Calculation: According to the rule, if a country’s population is PPP, the ideal size of its legislative body SSS should be approximately S=P1/3. For instance, if a country has a population of 27 million, the optimal legislative body size would be about 300 members, as 27,000,0001/3 = 300

Rationale Behind the Cube Root Rule:

  • Balance of Representation: The rule aims to strike a balance between having enough representatives to provide effective representation for citizens and not having so many that the legislative process becomes inefficient.
  • Historical Observation: The rule is based on empirical observation of various countries, where many legislative bodies approximate the cube root of their populations.
  • Scalability: It provides a scalable approach, meaning as populations grow, legislatures should expand at a manageable rate, avoiding the extremes of overrepresentation or underrepresentation.

Cube Root Rule in practice in the US:

us-house-sube-root.jpg 

I don't know about 700 (which is what the cube root would give for 350M, but the US House should be expanded to at least 500 - and that requires nothing but an act of Congress. But the real problem with representation is the Senate and that's a tougher nut to crack.

Posted
12 hours ago, gehringer_2 said:

I don't know about 700 (which is what the cube root would give for 350M, but the US House should be expanded to at least 500 - and that requires nothing but an act of Congress. But the real problem with representation is the Senate and that's a tougher nut to crack.

This probably won’t happen, but maybe reducing the responsibility of the Senate to being more like the House of Lords, more of a deliberating and delaying body than a full legislative body, would improve things? I don’t know, just spitballing.

Posted
17 hours ago, CMRivdogs said:

Gonna need to build a bigger Capitol Building. Should be right up Trump's alley, he likes to build stuff

Sure, if you want it in Mar-a-Lago where he’ll charge the govt rent.

Posted

Here are a bunch of maps dividing the eastern US from the western US. On that second one, I wonder whether the numbers would show if California were removed from the western US.

us-pop-in-two.jpg

east-west-usa.jpg 

Cantner_100thMeridianMap.jpg

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...