The original publication of Al Stump’s book was in 1961, the year Cobb died. A reprint of Stump’s book was done in 1993. Charles C. Alexander, a history professor at Ohio University, also did a Cobb biography in 1984 titled, Ty Cobb. Alexander is guilty of repeating some of Stump’s unfounded tales in his book.
Several years ago I read a Q&A that Charles Leershan did regarding previously published inaccuracies that he had uncovered in his research of Cobb’s life. Leershan personally questioned Alexander on several statements he made about Cobb in his book, Ty Cobb. When Leershan pressed Alexander for evidence on several of his statements in the book Alexander had made regarding Cobb’s character, Alexander conceded that he was only going by what had been written up to that point. I guess it should be no irony that the Introduction for the reprint of Stump’s, My Life in Baseball, in 1993 is written by Charles C. Alexander.