A guy who could neither hit nor field. In fact, Sutherland is one of only 19 non-pitchers in big league history who played at least 1,000 games and had both negative overall WAR and negative defensive WAR. At least he escaped the ignominy of having negative offensive career WAR, something his teammate Dan Meyer couldn't escape.
Yuliesky Betancourt was the last players to populate that list of nineteen. Based on what we know about baseball WAR now, we may never see another.