Yes, this is absolutely it.
So, going into it for next season, is there a roster fit for Carpenter and Malloy? I think with Cabrera retiring, there’s more room for a regular everyday DH. Now maybe Carpenter and Malloy split those duties while also getting defensive reps, I don’t know.
Keith Law mentioned getting to the point in the season where rookie status can be protected next season and brought up Colt Keith. He wasn’t all too optimistic about Keith at 3B but also didn’t shut it down. Anyways, he thought maybe the Tigers bring him up soon as generally teams have their best defensive coaches up at the MLB level. I don’t know whether this is copy & paste for all teams or for the Tigers specifically. I guess if that’s the case, do the Tigers employ this plan? And if so, would they also consider it for Malloy?
The other aspects Law brought up regarding minor leaguers being called up made sense. Teams would do it for guys they think are going to get serious burn next season. Rookies can get used to the culture at the big leagues. The competition is obviously a key factor (he mentioned the gap between the majors and minors and what a leap that can be for some guys). I think there’s merit to it.
But I think there’s also consideration to just playing everyday. So, maybe it’s to Keith’s advantage to be plugging away at the hot corner in Toledo to finish out that season, and then maybe promoted to finish out the Tiger regular season. They could always bump someone like Diaz or Ibanez in lieu of bringing up a prospect.