Believe it or not, I’ve defended Yzerman a lot up here. Has gotten harder the past couple of years. Canadian media and fans flipped on Yzerman after he signed Holl, Chiarot and Petry, which made so many familiar with them from Toronto and Montreal scratch their head. Canadians aren’t used to hockey execs moving at a relaxed pace and fans being mostly chill about it like Wings fans, instead of signing a Messier like the Canucks or Tavares like the Leafs or in Montreal’s case anyone with a French name. Not that making attention-grabbing signings or trades has worked out for them, as a Canadian team hasn’t won a Cup since ‘93, but it’s a different mentality. So the attached article from Sportsnet today, “Have Rebuilding Wings Already Hit Their Peak” is another sober outside perspective. I’m not familiar with writer John Beneteau but Sportsnet is the hockey establishment. Some soundbites:
https://www.sportsnet.ca/nhl/article/have-rebuilding-red-wings-already-hit-their-peak/
- At the root of Detroit's issues is that the team has struggled to develop prospects, which is a key factor in any rebuild that's committed to the draft. Detroit has made 50 draft picks in the past six years and only one picked outside of the first-round played a role on this year's team.
- Detroit lacks true elite, superstar power, which often is only something you can address at the draft and a pay off from sinking into a rebuild. But the Wings didn't have such luck.
- the production the team got from Dylan Larkin, Alex DeBrincat and Raymond paled in comparison to other core groups from contending teams. Raymond leads the Red Wings with 75 points this season, which ranks 28th league-wide. DeBrincat’s 67 points are 48th, while Larkin’s 66 is 54th.
- J.T. Compher (10 goals, 31 points in 73 games), Andrew Copp (10 goals, 23 points in 56 games) and Vladimir Tarasenko (10 goals, 31 points in 77 games) all disappointed this season. Each of these players are over 30 years old, have contracts for next season, and hold some form of no-trade clause. If Yzerman did want to move on from any of them, it won't be such an easy thing to accomplish.
- the blue line is anchored down by veterans Ben Chiarot, Erik Gustafsson, Justin Holl and Jeff Petry. Of that group, only Petry is on an expiring contract so, like with the collection of signed veteran forwards, Yzerman will be challenged to change over his group, let alone upgrade it.
- crowded crease of netminders that saw Cam Talbot, Alex Lyon, Ville Husso and puzzling trade deadline acquisition Petr Mrazek all make starts. Only Talbot (.905) finished with a save percentage above .900 and he (turning 38 in July) and Mrazek (33) are both under contract and figure to share the crease again next season.
- the fact is the Red Wings are now securely caught in the middle, the worst place any team wants to be. There's no clear path forward, optimism is waning, management's options are slimmer than you'd like, and other teams in the rebuild phase are passing them by.