I was a teenager from 1986-1993.....
But to me a teenager is really the years 13-16 ish. After that when driving you become more of an adult, more likely working a part time job, etc.
My favorites that brief time period that gets me on a nostalgia push are Motley Crue (Theater of Pain), Beastie Boys (License to Ill), Run DMC (Raising Hell) , Metallica (And Justice For All) , and Iron Maiden (Somewhere in Time and Seventh Son). Those are tapes I wore out.
Of course in our era music was also something you watched. I have more memories of watching Tom Petty videos rather than listening. If you knew a video was on all the time then I wouldn't feel the need to buy the tape. MTV was always on.