The main point is that Avila made the first offer to Correa and it was well below Correa’s known floor, so it was a fair accompli that Correa would turn it down. The only real unknown is whether Avila knew going in whether Correa would reject it. Anyone who’s ever done even a little negotiating for a living would know Correa would reject it, and since Avila has done even a little negotiating as GM, I assume he knew it. I’m famous for not giving Al much credit, but I’m giving him credit for at least knowing that. The Harris offer to Bregman was more serious because it reportedly was the highest dollar figure of any team, as opposed to Avila’s obvious lowball effort, but who knows, maybe Harris was making an offer he knew Bregman would turn down, too.
It was widely reported by national beat writers, including Olney, that Avila made the offer to Correa, and this entire debate is predicated on the fact of that. If you’re going to cast doubt on whether it even happened, or whether it was fake news instead, then we really have nothing more to debate here.