I still think there’s a not half-bad chance we go to arb with Jeimer. He was considered a good-hitting four-win player all the way up to the end of 2021; I find it unlikely that he has permanently fallen off the cliff in a career-ending way within a single year, at age 28, while playing in an historically-bad offensive coaching environment. I could see us taking the $7 million gamble to see whether he can be restored, because who else we got? Ryan Kreidler? Are we really ready to hand him 502+ plate appearances next year? Or do we simply add 3B to the long list of black-hole positions to fill from the outside?
Even if we don’t go to arb with him, I find it even less likely that we can DFA him and then simply sign him to a minor-league contract in an unimpeded way. There are lots of teams that would consider Jeimer an upgrade, or at least someone who can be fixed enough to repair their own 3B woes. A’s, Nationals, Diamondbacks, Royals, Reds, Giants—they all have uncertain situations at 3B right now. Even the Cubs might be willing to take a flyer on a Devil They Know. I really doubt no one else would even take a look at Jeimer if we cut him loose on the market.