If it makes anyone feel any better, here is how the 2021 super 5 free agent shortstops are doing YTD in 2023:
Playing at an excellent level: Seager
Playing like ****: Semien, Correa (when he plays at all), Baez
Not playing, for the foreseeable future: Story
So, it's sort of a cautionary tale about free agency. It seems like the ROI on free agent contracts frequently ends up being perceived to be negative.