I like McGriff a lot, but would have considered him to be borderline HOF...until Baines got in, then McGriff should have been a slam dunk. Mattingly couldn't carry his jock strap. As for Murphy, I am surprised that he does not get more love, he had a very high peak. But as always you compare any of these guys to Whitaker, and the question is just absurd and doesn't even deserve an answer.