I think Rogers is to be taken with a grain of salt. He’s a catcher for one, primarily a defense first catcher. Sure, he might have some pop, but I don’t think anyone considers him to much offense to begin with. And the other thing is his return to actual game action. He missed quite a bit of time as a catcher and as a hitter. I think that’s quite a bit to miss. Sure, he can remain part of the game planning while injured and working with pitchers from afar, but actively catching them is another thing. And then along those lines, how many different pitchers have the Tigers been through the past season plus?
Maton is a bit of a victim of the BABIP pendulum so far. He is striking out worse than and walking better than league averages. But his BABIP is also under .200. Looks like he might be going opposite field and fly ball too much? I don’t know. Perhaps the approach is affecting the results.