Why not? He had a good season at AAA last season. This may have been what you were getting to with the Granderson comparison, but it looks like he has some speed on the bases, too. Can he field well? It looks like most of his time has been spent in CF. I know Carpenter is a bit of a favorite for some around here, but the big league roster isn't a place for his glove right now with Cabrera also on the roster.