05/13/2026 7:10p EDT Detroit Tigers at New York Mets

[gehringer_2]

1 hour ago, chasfh said:

That pretty much sums up how I view Max Clark, which is very different from how I view Reese Olsen or Jackson Jobe. 

Reese is why Avila took so many 6' 4" pitchers. My biggest worry when they took Jobe what that with a guy who spun his breaking ball that hard you might as well block out the lost year for the TJ surgery in advance. If he comes back from TJ spinning the ball just as hard, I'd guess he can be effective but the arm will always be a time bomb.

[Tiger337]

1 hour ago, chasfh said:

We always have hopes for any player we see, even Gage Workman. When it comes to some level of expectation, I think of Max Clark as a universally-regarded position-player top prospect with no history of injuries, so I do expect positive contribution out of him.

Is that a guarantee? No, but I don’t think it’s a crapshoot, either. I think the chances we get something out of Max are far higher than the chances we get nothing out of him. Will he be an 8-win superstar? That’s rare, but it’s within a reasonable range of outcomes for him specifically. A 5-win All-Star? I think that’s fairly probable at some point, if not perennially. Will he be a consistent 2-win everyday guy? I think he should be at least that, although I’d be disappointed if that’s where he topped out. Will he be a complete sub-replacement bust? I think the chances of that are very low, and I would be shocked if stayed healthy, played as hard as he could and up to his capabilities, and he were to crap out like that. I think something dramatic would have to happen, like a terrible freak injury, a series of Parker Meadows injuries, or even a serious diagnosed illness, for us to get nothing out of him.

That pretty much sums up how I view Max Clark, which is very different from how I view Reese Olsen or Jackson Jobe. 

I didn't say it was a crapshoot.  Clark has a much better chance of succeeding than Workman or Jung or Hao Yu Lee.   It's silly to even talk about that.  However, I don't expect him to contribute much in the near future and there is no guarantee of future stardom, much like Torkelson, Greene and Mize when they were coming up.  MLB is hard.  I think it's unlikely that he becomes a below replacement bust too.  In fact, my expectations are close to the ones you mentioned.  The range of possible outcomes is wide though.  

Don't forget Jobe was universally regarded as one of the top couple of pitching prospects as recently as last year.  So, he's not a lot different from Clark in that respect.  

How do you view Olson and Jobe?

Edited 1 hour ago by Tiger337