papalawrence Posted May 24 Posted May 24 Can't wait to hear Harris' spin. He played a role in the Giants winning 107 in 2021 where most players played above their baseline. 2022 they came back to earth with 81 wins. 2023 78 wins. I think Det is far below baseline to even out late 2024 through mid 2025. They'll get on a streak, and I think they'll end up above Minnesota. But that's it Quote
monkeytargets39 Posted May 24 Posted May 24 (edited) So we just activated Melton and DFAd Seabold. Why Seabold, one of the guys who has been competent? Why not De Jesus? Why not Vanasco or SGL? Edited May 24 by monkeytargets39 Quote
Motor City Sonics Posted May 24 Posted May 24 Hey, Jansen didn't throw that many pitches, maybe he's available for Game 2 ! Quote
Tigerbomb13 Posted May 24 Posted May 24 Can’t wait to see four sub .500 ops guys in the lineup again. Does Jamai Jones lead off tonight? We are on the edge of our seats. Quote
monkeytargets39 Posted May 24 Posted May 24 All the botched plays for Baltimore and they still figure out to win. Even when other teams fall apart defensively they can overcome it. Quote
Motor City Sonics Posted May 24 Posted May 24 Last year's Trade Deadline. To come away with Charlie Morton and Chris Paddack and whomever that injured stiff from Cleveland was, Paul something, Was it Sewald? Did we even get 5 inning out of him? That showed me that the team was more interested in filling the Illitch family parking lots downtown than they were in actually winning. The the Pistons do the same crap. Great season - pickup up a stiff at the deadline who contributes nothing Guess I'll have to savor that 2008 Stanley Cup for a lot longer. Quote
Motor City Sonics Posted May 24 Posted May 24 4 minutes ago, monkeytargets39 said: All the botched plays for Baltimore and they still figure out to win. Even when other teams fall apart defensively they can overcome it. They didn't figure out how to win. We figured out how to lose. Quote
Motor City Sonics Posted May 24 Posted May 24 17 minutes ago, monkeytargets39 said: So we just activated Melton and DFAd Seabold. Why Seabold, one of the guys who has been competent? Why not De Jesus? Why not Vanasco or SGL? Because Reasons. Why are Short and Jones on this team? Reasons. Quote
motownblues Posted May 24 Posted May 24 Remember seeing Jansen last year. Wasn't much left then. Quote
NorthWoods Posted May 24 Posted May 24 5 minutes ago, Motor City Sonics said: Because Reasons. Why are Short and Jones on this team? Reasons. So Short can bat in these situations: J. Rogers: Ball, Ball, Strike looking, Strike looking, Ball, Ball, Rogers walked, Vierling to third, Torkelson to second Dietrich Enns relieved Keegan Akin Z. Short: Strike looking, Strike swinging, Short flied out to deep right Quote
NorthWoods Posted May 24 Posted May 24 2 minutes ago, kdog said: Short is playing in the second game. Einstein being stubborn to prove he's right. They should have DFA'd him and kept Seaboold Quote
tiger2022 Posted May 24 Posted May 24 The Tigers have the two smartest guys in the room leading this franchise Quote
monkeytargets39 Posted May 24 Posted May 24 9 minutes ago, kdog said: Short is playing in the second game. So are Jones and Wenceel Quote
NorthWoods Posted May 24 Posted May 24 48 minutes ago, monkeytargets39 said: So we just activated Melton and DFAd Seabold. Why Seabold, one of the guys who has been competent? Why not De Jesus? Why not Vanasco or SGL? "When healthy, Seabold has been pretty effective coming out of the pen, with a 3.45 ERA, 20.3% strikeout rate, and 7.2% walk rate over 15 2/3 innings." Quote
Adullin Posted May 24 Posted May 24 1 hour ago, UCFKNIGHT said: Most of you people, on this message board, disagree with the majority of my post, but Scott Harris and AJ Hinch should both be fired. The ownership and management of this team is disgusting? Why Hinch give the man some talent Quote
tiger2022 Posted May 24 Posted May 24 Just now, Adullin said: Why Hinch give the man some talent Hinch doesn't want any talent in the first place. He wants to show he can win with scrubs so he can back up his belief that he is the smartest manager in the history of baseball. I think he needs garbage can lids Quote
Sports_Freak Posted May 24 Posted May 24 1 hour ago, papalawrence said: Can't wait to hear Harris' spin. He played a role in the Giants winning 107 in 2021 where most players played above their baseline. 2022 they came back to earth with 81 wins. 2023 78 wins. I think Det is far below baseline to even out late 2024 through mid 2025. They'll get on a streak, and I think they'll end up above Minnesota. But that's it You think we'll win 62 games? 62-100? Well on our way. A finish of 42-67? We're 20-33 now... Quote
chasfh Posted May 25 Posted May 25 For us to believe we’re going to lose 100 games, we would have to believe we are a bad team no matter who’s playing on it, include Skubal, Melton, Javy, Gleyber, Carpenter, etc. 1 Quote
gehringer_2 Posted May 25 Posted May 25 (edited) 58 minutes ago, chasfh said: For us to believe we’re going to lose 100 games, we would have to believe we are a bad team no matter who’s playing on it, include Skubal, Melton, Javy, Gleyber, Carpenter, etc. I still have concerns I don't see the way out of. On the offensive side, my confidence level that Javy, Gleyber or Carpenter are going to add that much is low.. All three are fast joining the ranks of those those whose name has to be prefaced with 'the oft-injured.' Will any of them be able to stay on the field once back? Not to mention Javy isn't that big an offensive add under any circumstance. And Parker is already only about half a mis-step away from being a 'might have been' The pitching talent is going to be there, but you still have the problem of how you get Jansen and Flaherty off the field. It's not going to do any good to have better young arms able to pitch if the team keeps sending those two guys out there anyway. This management has been pretty bad about cutting bait on its mistakes in a timely fashion (Kenta?). How many games are they going to let those two lose? Edited May 25 by gehringer_2 Quote
chasfh Posted May 25 Posted May 25 17 minutes ago, gehringer_2 said: I still have concerns I don't see the way out of. On the offensive side, my confidence level that Javy, Gleyber or Carpenter are going to add that much is low.. All three are fast joining the ranks of those those whose name has to be prefaced with 'the oft-injured.' Will any of them be able to stay on the field once back? Not to mention Javy isn't that big an offensive add under any circumstance. And Parker is already only about half a mis-step away from being a 'might have been' The pitching talent is going to be there, but you still have the problem of how you get Jansen and Flaherty off the field. It's not going to do any good to have better young arms able to pitch if the team keeps sending those two guys out there anyway. This management has been pretty bad about cutting bait on its mistakes in a timely fashion (Kenta?). How many games are they going to let those two lose? You seriously don't think Javy, Gleyber, and Carpenter can add any more to the offense than Zack Short, Wenceel Perez, and Hao-Yu Lee? If that's true, then man, that really is fatalist woe-is-me thinking. I also don't think any team would ****-can Jansen for one bad outing after six straight practically flawless appearances. As for Flaherty, that's your most defensible move, although that would leave us having to backfill his innings with more bullpen days and pitching chaos. If that's what you'd prefer, I won't try to argue you out of that one. Quote
Shelton Posted May 25 Posted May 25 46 minutes ago, gehringer_2 said: I still have concerns I don't see the way out of. On the offensive side, my confidence level that Javy, Gleyber or Carpenter are going to add that much is low.. All three are fast joining the ranks of those those whose name has to be prefaced with 'the oft-injured.' Will any of them be able to stay on the field once back? Not to mention Javy isn't that big an offensive add under any circumstance. And Parker is already only about half a mis-step away from being a 'might have been' The pitching talent is going to be there, but you still have the problem of how you get Jansen and Flaherty off the field. It's not going to do any good to have better young arms able to pitch if the team keeps sending those two guys out there anyway. This management has been pretty bad about cutting bait on its mistakes in a timely fashion (Kenta?). How many games are they going to let those two lose? I feel like they rid themselves of Kenta at the right time. I think they have dug themselves too big of a hole to save this season, but they also aren’t gonna lose 100 games. Not that it really matters. Losing 80 or losing 100 still leaves us watching more football than we would like. 1 1 Quote
gehringer_2 Posted May 25 Posted May 25 (edited) 2 hours ago, chasfh said: You seriously don't think Javy, Gleyber, and Carpenter can add any more to the offense than Zack Short, Wenceel Perez, and Hao-Yu Lee? Not that I don't think they are miles better, I doubt how many PA we will get before some number of them are back on the IL. EDIT: I really would have been OK if Gleyber hadn't felt the need to reinforce the point today. Jansen has blown 4 saves out of 13 save opportunities. His walk rate and HR rate are the highest of his career, his GB the lowest. He strikes me as showing signs of being on borrowed time. OTOH, his velo seems be holding - which is in his favor. Edited May 25 by gehringer_2 Quote
chasfh Posted May 26 Posted May 26 10 hours ago, gehringer_2 said: Not that I don't think they are miles better, I doubt how many PA we will get before some number of them are back on the IL. EDIT: I really would have been OK if Gleyber hadn't felt the need to reinforce the point today. Jansen has blown 4 saves out of 13 save opportunities. His walk rate and HR rate are the highest of his career, his GB the lowest. He strikes me as showing signs of being on borrowed time. OTOH, his velo seems be holding - which is in his favor. Maybe you're right. Or maybe he's put some of the rougher times behind him and what we're seeing lately is real. One thing is for sure: we're gonna find out. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.