Shreve doesn’t seem to be a good pitcher either, but he’s also on a minor league deal. $3M isn’t much for a not good pitcher, sure. It just seems like there are better options than Cisnero, especially with all of the waiver wire claims being brought in along with the already in house options.
I would bet had Cisnero been nontendered, he’d have gotten no more than a minor league deal with an invite to camp and incentives based on making the major league roster out of camp, incentives for innings pitched, an opt out of the minor league deal after camp if he didn’t make the major league roster.