Tenacious D

I’d rather have Wenceel in the lineup than Colt.

It clearly hit the bat first, but even if it hadn’t, seems odd that you call a HBP when the batter squares up on the pitch.

Wow—they missed it.

Have to feel good about Melton and Montero being contributors next season. Pitching in a playoff series (and elimination game) is huge for them.

I hate him. Looks like a dickhead.

You just made my point for me. If they decide to trade him, it will be this offseason. I doubt they’ll let he and Skubal both walk.

Mize is a free agent at the end of ‘26. He probably has more trade value this offseason than risking his performance next season and getting little at the deadline. Plus, it does seem like the relationship is a bit strained. He would need to be replaced, but I would not be shocked to see him dealt.

A lot of it is reaction time—given the proximity to the plate, ball can come at you fast. Also, the only infield position where you can field the ball and not have first base in view, often requiring the pitcher to turn around to make a throw. Of course the Philly pitcher just didn’t execute, which happens to everyone. Just the most inopportune time.

Have to upgrade the offense somewhere. Greene (LF), Dingler (C), Keith (2B), Carpenter (RF/DH) seem fairly safe bets. I would guess that Baez (SS) is safe, too, until McGonigle is ready. I doubt they would upgrade there. I’d put Tork (1B) and Meadows (CF) as likely, but vulnerable to an external upgrade. The obvious positions to upgrade and bring in new talent are 3B and RF/DH, again. Also, probably a good reason that we held on to our position prospects who could be banging on the door next season, including Malloy, Jung, Anderson and Lee. Will Harris largely run back this combination of options or seek other help?

I felt Castillo was more effective against us. But he’ll be next up, if necessary.

Flaherty should move to the pen. Would be dominant for 1-2 innings. If the Tigers want hom to opt out. They should tell him that’s how they plan to use him. Agree that Mize could get dealt. Would create another hole, but they could patch via other trades/signings. I could see Tork getting dealt, too. Maybe a run after Pete Alonzo. I think they will go after 1-2 established bats after the way this season ended.

At least Phillies fans are known for their civility and compassion

Always hated math

Tigers are 4-3 so far this postseason. And 1-0 in elimination games played on the road.

Who are these guys and what did they do with my team?

McGonigle was not a free agent supplemental pick—he was a competitive balance.

Can we keep the Skubal re-signing debate to the “Will Skubal re-sign?” thread? I have enough to be stressed about already here.

Wonder if it is a bit demoralizing for the pitchers?

I think Skubal will be open to a return. And I believe the Tigers will make a reasonable effort to retain him. However, I think what he’ll command and get will be unreasonable and he’ll ultimately be overpaid by someone else. It won’t be because the Tigers are cheap (always a lazy, false narrative) or because Skubal was greedy. Just business.

Sunny Leone? Wow

Sarnia? The gateway to Ontario!

Mine, too. Majoring in Lacrosse, unfortunately.

Would love to get a firsthand account from Idaho Bert on this. Realize he was only in middle school, but hopefully still has fond memories.

However, must win today! Amirite?

They want Cal Raleigh and Julio Rodriguez from a marketing/fan interest perspective. Plus, for the Boomers and Gen Xers, this is the battle of the expansion teams.